Enjoying a cozy evening with a large bowl of popcorn and a movie is a classic delight. Traditionally, microwave popcorn was the go-to choice, but these bags often contain unhealthy ingredients and aren’t environmentally friendly. Nowadays, you can easily create your own popcorn using a reusable maker for a fresher and more delicious snack.
Today, there are numerous popcorn-making options, including stovetop, electric, and microwave models. These tools allow you to craft flavorful popcorn with your favorite seasonings, from parmesan to sea salt and black pepper. Whether you prefer a stovetop model for a classic movie theater taste, a microwave version for convenience, or an electric maker for ease of use, there’s a perfect choice for every budget.
To find the best popcorn makers, we popped countless batches, evaluating each for consistency, flavor, and the number of unpopped kernels. Our top recommendations span stovetop, microwave, and electric models, ensuring you get the best popcorn-making experience possible.
Best Overall
Wabash Valley Farms Whirley Pop Color Changing Popcorn Maker
Pros
The popcorn it produces is exceptional, and the color-changing feature adds both fun and functionality.
Cons
You need to be actively involved throughout the popcorn-making process, and it’s a bit bulky to store.
Review
We selected this popcorn maker as our top pick for a reason—it delivers outstanding popcorn. The classic Whirley Pop stovetop model has been updated with a color-changing feature: it shifts from red to yellow as it heats and back to red when the popcorn is ready. This is particularly engaging for kids.
Our tests revealed that it produces a large batch of consistently delicious, crunchy, and chewy popcorn with very few unpopped kernels. While you need to continuously crank the handle, the process is straightforward. We did notice some scorching on the bottom of the pan, but the popcorn itself remained unburned.
We recommend wearing an oven mitt as the steam can be quite hot. The cleanup is easy; if you use it frequently, simply wipe it down after it cools (indicated by the return to a full red color). For longer storage, a bit of soapy water will do the trick.
Specifications
- Dimensions: 16.69 x 9.84 x 7.95 inches
- Capacity: Yields 24 cups (6 quarts)
- Material and Care: Made of aluminum and metal with nylon gears. Wipe down after use; for longer storage, clean with soapy water and dry thoroughly.
Best Microwave
Chef’n Pop Top Microwave Popcorn Maker
Pros
It’s a single-piece design, eliminating the need for a separate lid.
Cons
The colors slightly faded after being washed in the dishwasher.
Review
This straightforward silicone microwave popper features an innovative single-piece design that combines functionality with fun. It can be compactly folded for easy storage and expands in the microwave as the popcorn pops. Additionally, it has a fill-to-edge indicator, removing the need for a measuring cup. We found the silicone to be more robust compared to other models we tested.
This popcorn maker doesn’t require oil or butter to produce a tasty batch. The easy-hold tabs make it simple to handle when removing it from the microwave, and it consistently produced chewy, evenly cooked popcorn in our tests. Although it is dishwasher safe, we recommend hand-washing to preserve its longevity. We observed that the colors tend to fade and become spotty in the dishwasher.
Specifications
- Dimensions: 7 x 7 x 4 inches
- Capacity: 10 cups
- Material and Care: Made of silicone. Dishwasher-safe, but hand-washing is recommended.
Best Single Serve
Ecolution Micro-Pop Microwave Popcorn Popper
Pros
This popcorn maker fits in any microwave and has a convenient feature for melting butter on top.
Cons
It produces a small amount of popcorn, suitable only for a single serving.
Review
For those who prefer glass over silicone, this compact yet powerful popcorn maker delivers evenly popped, chewy popcorn. Its small size is ideal for single servings or for use in smaller microwaves, such as those in dorm rooms. The large handle makes it easy to carry.
The manufacturer recommends using this popper in a microwave with a turntable for optimal results. The lid serves a dual purpose as a measuring cup for the kernels and a spot to place butter, which melts over the popcorn as it pops. Available in various colors, this popcorn maker also makes for a fun gift. Cleaning is straightforward, as it can be easily rinsed or placed in the dishwasher. If you like this model but need a larger capacity for your family, Ecolution also offers a 3-quart size.
Specifications
- Dimensions: 7.5 x 6 x 5.13 inches
- Capacity: 1.5 quarts, yields about 4 cups
- Material and Care: Borosilicate glass. Dishwasher-safe (top rack recommended).
Best for Big Batches
Franklin’s Popcorn Machine Popper
Pros
It produces a large quantity of delicious popcorn, comparable to what you’d find at a movie theater.
Cons
It’s the priciest machine we tested, and like most stainless steel items, it can scratch easily.
Review
Designed to replicate the movie theater popcorn experience, this high-end stovetop popcorn maker is ideal for those who love making popcorn at home. Constructed from solid aluminum with a wooden handle, this model also features durable gears and comes with a lifetime guarantee. Although it’s somewhat bulky for storage, its sleek black coating gives it a stylish, retro look that can be proudly displayed on your kitchen range.
To operate, simply add oil, wait for it to heat, then add the kernels and start churning once you hear the first few pops. You can also add salt if desired. Unlike other models we tested that produced chewier popcorn, this one resulted in perfectly crunchy popcorn. Similar to our top pick, it can make nearly 24 cups of popcorn, providing enough for the whole family in just a few minutes. While this model requires hand washing, the extra effort is worth it to ensure its longevity given its premium price.
Specifications
- Dimensions: 11.6 x 8 x 16.6 inches
- Capacity: 24 cups
- Material and Care: Aluminum. Wipe out for regular use, or clean with soapy water when used less frequently.
Best Electric
Presto Poplite Hot Air Popper
Pros
The machine is easy to set up and doesn’t require oil to make popcorn.
Cons
It needs to be plugged in and isn’t as aesthetically pleasing as stovetop models.
Review
Our top choice for an electric popcorn maker is the Presto Air Popper, which offers a quick and straightforward setup without needing any oil, making it a healthier option. It uses hot air to pop the kernels and directs them through a chute into your bowl. In just a few minutes, it can produce about 18 cups of popcorn, enough for two large bowls.
For those who like butter with their popcorn, the machine includes a butter warmer that also serves as a measuring cup. Just add the desired amount of butter, and it will melt while the popcorn pops. During testing, we found the plastic construction to be thicker and more durable than that of competitors, and it doesn’t get as hot. The popcorn it produces is light, crisp, and large.
Cleaning this machine is a breeze—the butter warmer can be washed with soap and water, and the rest of the machine, including the clear plastic cover and cup, can be wiped down with a damp cloth. Since no oil is used, it doesn’t get very dirty.
Specifications
- Dimensions: 6 x 9 x 13.7 inches
- Capacity: Yields 18 cups
- Material and Care: Plastic. Wipe down with a damp cloth.
Best Splurge
Popsmith The Popper
Pros
It produces large batches and includes convenient flavor packs.
Cons
It’s not a hands-free tool; you need to monitor it while in use.
Review
For a stovetop popcorn maker that can handle large batches, is user-friendly, and looks stylish, we recommend the Popper. This model works with pre-measured packets of kernels, seasoning salt, and a coconut oil base (available in classic butter or kettle corn flavors). It also offers the flexibility to experiment with your own popcorn flavors. Simply preheat your stovetop to medium for two minutes, add the packet contents, and start turning the handle when the popping begins. Made from stainless steel, it’s dishwasher-safe, compatible with all stovetops, and available in five colors.
Cleaning is straightforward, whether you opt to wash it by hand or use the dishwasher. While using the Popper is relatively easy, it is a manual device, so you need to stay nearby while it’s in use. Over time, the turning mechanism may cause minor wear on the color around the exterior rim, but it’s not very noticeable. Although it costs nearly $200, it’s a worthwhile investment if you frequently make popcorn for groups or display your cookware on open shelving.
Specifications
- Dimensions: 9 x 7 inches
- Capacity: Not specified
- Material and Care: Stainless steel. Hand wash or dishwasher-safe.
Our Favorite Popcorn Maker
Our top choice was the Original Whirley Pop color-changing popcorn popper with nylon gears. While most stovetop models delivered excellent results, this color-changing version stood out as our favorite. It consistently produced flawless popcorn with no unpopped kernels and changed color when heated. If you’re making popcorn for just one person, we recommend the Ecolution Micro-Pop Microwave Popcorn Popper. For an electric option, our pick is the Presto Air Popper.
Factors to Consider
Type and Ease of Use
Your initial choice is whether to go with a stovetop, electric, or microwave popcorn popper. Stovetop models tend to yield the best quality and flavor, though they require continuous cranking for about three minutes. If you want oil-free popcorn, consider an electric or microwave option. Microwave popcorn makers offer a simple method for creating popcorn that’s better than store-bought while retaining a familiar process.
Capacity
The popcorn makers we evaluated varied in capacity from about four cups, ideal for a single serving, to up to 24 cups, sufficient for a whole family. Consider how many people you intend to serve with each batch to determine the appropriate size for your needs.
Ease of Cleaning
Typically, popcorn makers are straightforward to clean, with some being dishwasher-safe. If this is a priority, opt for one designed to maintain its appearance over time. Some models feature multiple parts or components, while others are more streamlined for convenience. When selecting your popcorn maker, consider whether you prefer an all-in-one design. Regardless of your choice, carefully review the cleaning instructions specific to your machine.
How We Tested Popcorn Makers
To identify the optimal popcorn maker, we prepared numerous batches of popcorn according to the manufacturer’s guidelines. During each test, we measured popping times, counted unpopped kernels to gauge efficiency, and evaluated taste, texture, and consistency. We also noted the yield of each batch and assessed the level of hands-on involvement needed for a successful outcome. Additionally, we considered ease of cleaning and any special design features that enhanced user experience.
Frequently Asked Questions
How do popcorn makers work?
Popcorn makers operate differently depending on their type. Microwave popcorn makers typically do not require oil; kernels are placed inside with a loosely fitted or vented lid, and heat from the microwave causes them to pop. Stovetop models use a combination of oil, kernels, and heat, requiring constant stirring to prevent burning. Electric popcorn makers usually employ hot air circulation to pop the kernels efficiently.
What kind of oil do you use for a popcorn machine?
The choice of oil for a popcorn machine depends on the type of machine and desired flavor. Coconut oil, used in our testing, provides a distinctive yellow color and flavor, though it is higher in saturated fat. Many movie theaters use coconut or canola oil. For healthier options, avocado oil, which has a high smoke point, or olive oil can be used in machines that require oil.
Can you use a popcorn maker without oil?
Yes, many popcorn makers can be operated without oil. Microwave and electric models often do not require oil until after popping. However, most stovetop models necessitate some oil. Always refer to the specific instructions for your popcorn maker.
How do I make stovetop popcorn?
Instructions for stovetop popcorn makers vary, but typically involve adding oil and kernels. In our tests, once the oil heats and kernels sizzle, continue stirring with the hand crank until popping slows to occasional pops with a few seconds between them, or until you encounter resistance and cannot crank further.
Can you make popcorn in an air fryer?
While it’s technically possible to make popcorn in an air fryer, it’s not generally recommended. It takes longer compared to stovetop or microwave methods, and there’s a risk of kernels getting caught in the heating element, potentially causing fire or smoke, or damaging the air fryer. Achieving successful results may also require multiple attempts. For making popcorn, stovetop or microwave models are strongly recommended.
What Didn’t Make the List
We evaluated several other popcorn makers that didn’t meet our standards. The Cuisinart Pop and Serve Popcorn Maker surprised us the most. Although Cuisinart typically produces reliable products, this microwave popcorn maker had a vented lid that resulted in slightly soggy kernels and did not withstand dishwasher cleaning well. The Original Hotpop left numerous unpopped kernels, while the Original Salbree didn’t quite match the performance of other makers. The Wabash Valley Farms Original Whirley Pop Aluminum performed solidly but showed more wear and difficult-to-remove scorch marks compared to other stovetop models. We also tested electric models like the Cuisinart Easy Pop Air Popper and the Dash SmartStore, both of which did not perform as well as the competition.
